By College Football Analyst Josh Buchanan for TonySoftli.com
| First Team | |||
| QB | Jason Vander Laan | 6-4, 241, Sr. | Ferris State |
| RB | Cameron McDondle | 5-8, 196, Sr. | CSU-Pueblo |
| RB | Anthony Bilal | 5-7, 170, Sr. | Lake Erie |
| WR | Marquise Cushon | 5-10, 162, Sr. | Pittsburg State |
| WR | Dez Stewart | 6-2, 190, Sr. | Ohio Dominican |
| TE | Tim Brown | 6-3, 235, Sr. | West Chester |
| OL | Cory Tucker | 6-4, 285, Sr. | Slippery Rock |
| OL | Joe Ray | 6-1, 270, Sr. | Lenoir-Rhyne |
| OL | Nate Theaker | 6-6, 303, Sr. | Wayne State (MI) |
| OL | Herschel Prater | 6-5, 305, Sr. | Minnesota Mankato |
| OL | Travis Hening | 6-5, 305, Sr. | East Central |
| DL | Sydney Omameh | 6-4, 255, Sr. | Ohio Dominican |
| DL | Matt Judon | 6-4, 255, Sr. | Grand Valley State |
| DL | Josh Gordon | 6-2, 250, Sr. | Minnesota Mankato |
| DL | Anthony McDaniel | 6-1, 280, Sr. | Bowie State |
| LB | Connor Harris | 6-0, 235, Jr. | Lindenwood |
| LB | Kevin Clarke | 6-1, 210, Jr. | Indiana (PA) |
| LB | Tyler Henderson | 6-3, 235, Sr. | Minnesota Mankato |
| DB | Isaiah Davis | 5-10, 185, Sr. | Central Washington |
| DB | Solomon St. Pierre | 5-11, 171, Sr. | Sioux Falls |
| DB | Jordan Shaw | 6-2, 215, Sr. | Shorter |
| DB | Michael Jordan | 6-0, 200, Sr. | Missouri Western State |
| K | Brent Wahle | 6-2, 175, Sr. | Ohio Dominican |
| P | Austin Pitchford | 6-1, 185, Soph. | Colorado Mesa |
| AP | Paul Revis | 5-9, 165, Soph. | Western Oregon |
| Second Team | |||
| QB | Kyle Washington | 6-5, 205, Sr. | Angelo State |
| RB | Geremy Alridge-Mitchell | 5-8, 203, Sr. | West Texas A&M |
| RB | Calvinaugh Jones | 5-9, 200, Sr. | Concord |
| WR | Jalen Hendricks | 6-2, 205, Sr. | Livingstone College |
| WR | Garry Brown | 6-1, 200, Jr. | California (PA) |
| TE | Cole Spurgeon | 6-3, 235, Sr. | Colorado Mines |
| OL | Zach Voytek | 6-5, 300, Jr. | New Haven |
| OL | Brian Berzanski | 6-5, 310, Sr. | Central Missouri |
| OL | Jordan Morgan | 6-4, 300, Jr. | Kutztown |
| OL | Zach Martinez | 6-6, 301, Sr. | CSU-Pueblo |
| OL | Jim Walsh | 6-5, 310, Sr. | Grand Valley State |
| DL | Toni Pulu | 6-3, 285, Sr. | Texas A&M Commerce |
| DL | Justin Zimmer | 6-3, 258, Sr. | Ferris State |
| DL | Brandon Yost | 6-2, 280, Sr. | Northwest Missouri State |
| DL | Clayton Callicutt | 6-4, 275, Sr. | Angelo State |
| LB | Logan Genz | 6-2, 220, Sr. | Arkansas Tech |
| LB | Kenny Murphy | 6-2, 240, Sr. | Valdosta State |
| LB | D’Gary Wallace | 6-0, 205, Sr. | Urbana (OH) |
| DB | Cedrique Chaney | 6-0, 195, Sr. | Central Washington |
| DB | CJ Davis | 5-9, 188, Jr. | Shepherd |
| DB | Jordan Bowman | 6-0, 210, Jr. | California (PA) |
| DB | Bryce Enyard | 6-1, 188, Sr. | Northwest Missouri State |
| K | Conner Hollabaugh | 5-10, 181, Jr. | West Texas A&M |
| P | Kyle Clark | 6-4, 170, Sr. | Newberry |
| AP | Isaiah Davis | 5-10, 186, Sr. | Central Washington |
